Seizure of Albert
In March, conservation officers entered Tony Cavallaro’s home in Hamburg, a suburb of Buffalo, New York, and seized his 11-foot, 750-pound alligator named Albert. The officers sedated Albert, taped his mouth shut, and transported him away, citing the expiration of Cavallaro’s license to keep the reptile in 2021 and its subsequent non-renewal.
Lawsuit Against DEC
Cavallaro has filed a lawsuit with the New York State Supreme Court against the Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC), contesting the agency’s refusal to renew his license. His attorney, Peter Kooshoian, argues that the denial was not “factually based.” They hope to reinstate the license and negotiate or litigate Albert’s return.
DEC’s Position
The DEC, which has declined to comment on pending litigation, previously stated that Albert’s enclosure did not adequately prevent contact with people and that the alligator suffered from blindness and spinal issues. Cavallaro disputes these claims.
Public Support
The seizure, captured on video, and Cavallaro’s shared moments with Albert in a custom indoor pool have garnered widespread support. Signs reading “Bring Albert Home” are visible in neighborhood lawns, and over 4,500 followers track Cavallaro’s efforts on Facebook.
Regulatory Issues
The licensing issue arose from a 2020 regulatory change by the DEC regarding the possession of dangerous animals. After Cavallaro’s license expired in 2021, the DEC stated that he failed to comply with updated standards ensuring public safety. Cavallaro contends that the DEC did not adhere to its own licensing requirements for existing wild animal owners.
